Mac McAnally and I wrote the song “Old Flame.” I can’t believe it has been 30 years

March 5, 2016

“Mac McAnally and I wrote the song ‘Old Flame.’ I can’t believe it has been 30 years. We were tossing a frisbee and trying for 100 catches in a row. Once we did that, we would write a country song. We started talking about old girlfriends and I said let’s write a song about old flames. He said that was a good title. I wrote it down and we started banging it off of the guitar. Mac was making it a little complex for a country song and he took out a few chords and simplify it. We went to a studio and demoed it. The band Alabama was just getting started and they were playing a show in a bar in our hometown in Muscle Shoals. The town had just gone wet. I thanked them for cutting one of my other songs on their last album. They were glad to meet me and asked if I had any other songs. I had the cassette of “Old Flame” in my pocket to take home and play for my wife. We listened to it on their bus. After the song, there was silence and Randy Owens asked me to play it again because he had chill bumps. I played it again and they asked for the cassette. That was the only copy of the song, but I had to give it to them. A few days later they were cutting it in the studio. The song became a country standard. That day writing in my living room with Mac, I never believed that could have happened. We were just writing a country song. I was driving to Guntersville to fish with a friend the first time I heard ‘Old Flame’ on the radio. It went crazy after that and in eight weeks it was #1 for four weeks. After that, the doors of Nashville opened and were able to follow up with other success. I had a couple of other smaller hits. “Why Does it Have to be Wrong or Right?” was #1 for Restless Heart and “Stand a Little Rain” was #1 for the Nitty Gritty Dirt Band. I was also a fisheries ecologist. I retired from that, but I am still a songwriter.”

4 Comments

  1. Barry

    Great story! “Old Flame” is on my top
    Ten list of country tunes.
    I think it’s right up there with
    Stand By Your Man..He Stopped
    Her Today..etc

    Reply
    • Ryan Poythress

      Donny, so good to see you in articles like this. The time I spent with you all those weeks on the boat working were some great times and I still tell people I worked with a country song writer that is a great person. You kept me on my toes with my Latin.

      Reply
  2. Cindy burnett

    One of my all time favorites. Great song

    Reply
  3. Linda Hargett

    I absolutely love this song, I am from El Dorado, Ar.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 More Southern Souls